Earlier than the prescription, there was a life in movement — sharp, decided, and stuffed with promise.
In 1988, throughout a bodily examination earlier than coming into nursing faculty, his ldl cholesterol was flagged as elevated. He was 19 years outdated, with no vital medical historical past. He started his nursing profession in 1991, beginning in medical-surgical items earlier than discovering his true calling three years later in important care.
Christopher thrived as a high-functioning ICU nurse, identified for his competence, compassion, and calm below stress. He had plans to go even additional — to change into a Licensed Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA), a long-held dream. Outdoors the hospital, he remained lively by means of martial arts, fishing, and out of doors pursuits. He was, by all measures, formidable and deeply engaged with the world round him — lively, vibrant, and outwardly properly.
The choice to begin Lipitor got here swiftly. Christopher was younger, lively, and seemingly wholesome, however with a complete ldl cholesterol of 290 mg/dl (7.5 mmol/L) and a robust household historical past, his physician recommended a statin. Given his function within the ICU and his belief in medical protocols, Christopher didn’t hesitate. He started 10 mg of Lipitor, simply as numerous others had.
“I assumed I knew all the things about these medicine,” he stated. “I used to be a nurse. I trusted the proof. However I’d solely been taught what the pharmaceutical reps needed us to know.”
He started Lipitor with out incident. At the least, that’s the way it appeared — till months later, when the primary signs began to floor.
The Descent
It began with episodes of sleep paralysis — terrifying and unexplained. Christopher had by no means skilled something prefer it. He would wake in the course of the evening, acutely aware however frozen, unable to maneuver his limbs or communicate. These episodes grew to become continual and extreme. He feared he was having a stroke.
In time, different signs adopted: relentless complications, profound fatigue, and a fog that crept into his ideas. He usually slept as much as 18 hours a day, unable to get away from bed. On some days, the exhaustion was so overwhelming that he referred to as in sick to his job as a nurse—one thing he had hardly ever carried out earlier than.
His habits grew to become more and more erratic. His spouse Anne discovered herself witnessing a daunting transformation. One evening, at 3 a.m., Anne woke to seek out him digging by means of the kitchen trash. “I’m in search of milk,” he instructed her. They didn’t hold milk within the rubbish. One other evening, she discovered the entrance door ajar and Christopher wandering down the road in his underwear. When she referred to as to him, he didn’t reply. When she reached him, he didn’t acknowledge her.
They went to the emergency room. The analysis included primary laboratory assessments and a neurological examination, all of which have been inside regular limits. No imaging was carried out. The docs discovered nothing alarming and identified an atypical migraine, prescribing Imitrex. Anne pushed for imaging, however it was deemed pointless.
Anxious and pissed off, Anne referred to as her sister-in-law, a nurse, who inspired her to telephone Christopher’s main care doctor immediately. He agreed to order an MRI of the mind. The outcomes have been revealing, however it might be weeks earlier than anybody adopted up on them.
By the point Christopher was hospitalized on the College of Wisconsin in Madison, his deterioration was full. He couldn’t stroll, feed himself, or acknowledge Anne, their son, or his mother and father. He was incontinent and nonverbal. He described himself as having change into like “a 90-year-old man with end-stage Alzheimer’s illness.”
An MRI revealed innumerable lesions scattered throughout his mind, together with the corpus callosum and brainstem.
A mind biopsy confirmed widespread neuronal apoptosis. Electron microscopy revealed mitochondrial abnormalities: disarrayed cristae, swollen organelles, and dense vacuolization.
🔬 Mind Biopsy Findings
There’s one focal space having vacuolization of each neuropil and neuronal cytoplasm. A number of the vacuolization is perivascular. Uncommon small meningeal and one cortical vessel present lymphocyte cuffing. Vessels present intraluminal fibrinoid deposits…
Electron micrographs present irregular mitochondria in oligodendroglia and in cells of the vascular wall — both clean muscle and/or endothelia. The irregular mitochondria have thickened, disarrayed cristae and inclusions of lysosomal and autophagic vacuoles…
FINAL DIAGNOSIS: LIGHT AND ELECTRON MICROSCOPY:
- 1) Proper Frontal Cortex: Spongiform encephalopathy, focal, with irregular mitochondria (EM)
- 2) Proper Frontal Meninges: No pathologic modifications
COMMENT: The modifications seen by gentle and electron microscopy are most in line with a mitochondrial encephalopathy resembling MELAS syndrome.
The analysis was sobering: a mitochondrial encephalopathy, most in line with MELAS — a situation he had as soon as examine in passing however by no means imagined he’d face personally. For Christopher, a nurse who had cared for sufferers with dignity and vigilance, the belief that he was now the affected person, confused, silent, and profoundly susceptible, struck with deep emotional drive. However then, one thing shifted.
Inside 24 hours of beginning a mitochondrial cocktail — a mix of nutritional vitamins, amino acids, and Coenzyme Q10 — Christopher requested to make use of the restroom. It was the primary coherent sentence he’d spoken in weeks. He acknowledged Anne. He started to reply.
He wasn’t cured. However he was returning.
Weeks later, although nonetheless weak, he was discharged — alive, alert, and starting to hope. That hope quickly turned to dedication, as Christopher began looking for solutions that will ultimately lead him to a groundbreaking analysis research — and a telephone name that will change all the things.
🔋 What Are Mitochondria?
Mitochria are tiny organelles inside our cells, usually referred to as the cell’s “energy vegetation.” They generate the vitality (ATP) that powers practically each organic operate — from muscle contraction to mind exercise. Additionally they assist regulate calcium ranges, cell loss of life, and immune responses. When mitochondria fail, the implications ripple throughout the whole physique.
🧬 What Is MELAS Syndrome?
MELAS (Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathy, Lactic Acidosis, and Stroke-like episodes) is a maternally inherited mitochondrial dysfunction, mostly attributable to the mtDNA A3243G mutation.
It presents with recurrent stroke-like episodes, seizures, myopathy, lactic acidosis, and progressive neurocognitive decline. Prognosis includes genetic testing and affirmation by biopsy exhibiting irregular mitochondria.
The UCSD Name
A couple of weeks after Christopher returned house, nonetheless in restoration, he and Anne occurred to observe an interview on Good Morning America. The visitor was Dr. Beatrice Golomb, principal investigator of the UCSD Statin Results Research. She was discussing uncommon unintended effects reported by statin customers — signs that echoed a lot of what Christopher had simply lived by means of.
Anne turned to him and stated, “That you must enroll.”
Christopher hesitated. “I’m an RN,” he stated. “It’s my job to know what I’m giving to sufferers. And there’s no manner the Lipitor I took precipitated all this.”
However out of respect for Anne — and a lingering sense that one thing wasn’t including up — he agreed. He contacted the research staff and had his medical information forwarded to them.
Months later, the telephone rang. It was Dr. Golomb.
She instructed Christopher that he wasn’t alone. A number of different sufferers within the research had skilled comparable signs, together with cognitive decline, muscle injury, and profound fatigue. Their mind and muscle biopsies seemed practically equivalent to his.
Golomb had referred their circumstances to Dr. Doug Wallace, a world-renowned mitochondrial geneticist on the College of California, Irvine. Wallace reviewed the findings and provided a sobering conclusion: Christopher probably had a mitochondrial DNA mutation that had been dormant — till Lipitor triggered a cascade.
“The statin,” Wallace believed, “opened the gates.”
The decision was each validating and devastating. Christopher had spent years questioning himself. Now he had solutions — however no straightforward options.
🔬 The UCSD Statin Results Research
Led by Dr. Beatrice Golomb on the College of California, San Diego, the UCSD Statin Results Research was one of many first large-scale efforts to systematically examine the unintended effects of statins — not simply the plain ones, however the refined, often-dismissed signs sufferers reported: fatigue, reminiscence loss, muscle ache, cognitive fog.
Not like conventional trials, which frequently exclude sufferers who don’t tolerate remedy, this research aimed to take heed to those that struggled. It gathered detailed surveys, medical information, and in some circumstances, tissue samples to discover potential mechanisms of hurt.
For sufferers like Christopher, it provided one thing that had been lacking from the broader dialog: scientific validation that uncommon, critical unintended effects have been actual and warranted additional investigation.
Life After Lipitor
Rehabilitation was lengthy and exhausting. Christopher labored with speech therapists, bodily therapists, and neuropsychologists. For months, his objective was easy: to regain a sliver of his former self. He needed to stroll once more with out help. To carry a dialog. To recollect his son’s title with out looking for it.
Finally, he returned to work, cautiously optimistic, grateful to be alive. He took a place as a staff’ compensation case supervisor at American Household Insurance coverage. But it surely didn’t final.
Duties that when took him hours now took days. He struggled to retain data, comply with sequences, and full types that he had as soon as mastered blindfolded. Sooner or later, his supervisor entered his workplace in tears. “What used to take you a day,” she stated, “is now taking greater than per week.”
She wasn’t being merciless. She was being sincere. The work was now not appropriate along with his cognitive talents. Christopher packed up his desk and went house.
That second marked a distinct form of collapse — not neurological, however existential. He was 34 years outdated. He had labored since he was 12. And now, for the primary time in his life, he was out of labor.
He spiraled. The melancholy was deep and unfamiliar. He considered the sufferers he had handled through the years — those he’d handed Lipitor prescriptions to and not using a second thought. He questioned: had any of them gone by means of what he had? Had anybody listened?
At one level, Christopher got here near ending his life. However Anne satisfied him to see a therapist. That call — and the love that led to it — saved him.
Regardless of all the things he had misplaced, Christopher held on to one factor: the intuition to care. Some days, he wrote down notes from the medical literature, attempting to make sense of what had occurred. He missed nursing deeply, however even in silence, he discovered goal. “I’m nonetheless a nurse,” he would say, “even if I don’t clock in.” Over time, that resilience grew to become his compass, not towards a treatment, however towards which means.
As we speak, he lives with persistent muscle ache, peripheral neuropathy, and reminiscence deficits that restrict his each day functioning. However he wakes every day with gratitude — and with goal. He devotes his vitality to studying all the things about ldl cholesterol, statins, and the real-world penalties of remedy choices. He speaks. He writes. He educates.
He’s nonetheless, in each manner that issues, a nurse.
Statins, MELAS, and Mitochondrial Vulnerability
Christopher’s restoration was partial, however his sense of goal was clear. Now not in a position to follow as a nurse, he turned his vitality inward — studying obsessively, attempting to find clues. He devoured scientific literature on ldl cholesterol metabolism, statin pharmacology, and mitochondrial biology. Within the course of, he found one thing unsettling: his expertise wasn’t remoted. And neither was the science.
Though the overwhelming majority of sufferers tolerate statins with out critical points, rising research have proven how these medicine could adversely have an effect on people with latent mitochondrial vulnerabilities, together with these with circumstances like MELAS.
MELAS is a uncommon dysfunction attributable to mutations in mitochondrial DNA. It primarily impacts tissues with excessive vitality demand, such because the mind and muscle tissue, and sometimes presents with signs like seizures, cognitive decline, lactic acidosis, or stroke-like episodes. In Christopher’s case, the options have been refined at first, however they progressed shortly and dramatically.
Statins decrease ldl cholesterol by blocking the mevalonate pathway. Nevertheless, that pathway additionally produces Coenzyme Q10, an integral part in mitochondrial ATP manufacturing.
In sufferers with latent mitochondrial issues like MELAS, mevalonate pathway suppression can tip a fragile steadiness. ATP manufacturing falls. Oxidative stress rises. In tissues with excessive vitality calls for, such because the mind and muscle, the implications will be catastrophic.
This was a turning level for Christopher: “100% of my objective is to make individuals conscious that mevalonate blockade just isn’t with out probably devastating dangers,” he instructed me. “Dr. Beatrice Golomb as soon as stated statins provide lower than a 1% absolute danger discount — and should have unintended effects in as much as 20% of customers.”
Statin-induced suppression of CoQ10 can result in mitochondrial dysfunction, impairing vitality manufacturing, rising oxidative stress, and disrupting calcium steadiness. In sufferers like Christopher, this may unmask or speed up beforehand silent mitochondrial pathology.
This mechanism may assist clarify his dramatic response to mitochondrial help remedy. By replenishing Coenzyme Q10, his cells could have partially recovered their skill to provide vitality and stabilize important mobile processes.
One notable instance comes from a 2024 research by Ryan and colleagues, who demonstrated that high-dose atorvastatin (80 mg/day) considerably decreased skeletal muscle mitochondrial respiration after simply eight weeks in chubby however in any other case wholesome people.
The decline in oxidative phosphorylation capability exceeded 30% — a putting discovering that confirmed statins can immediately impair mitochondrial energetics, even in individuals with out prior mitochondrial illness. This raises legit concern for these with latent or inherited mitochondrial vulnerabilities.
These adversarial results stay uncommon, however their signs — mind fog, fatigue, muscle ache — are frequent and nonspecific. That makes them straightforward to miss. A number of printed circumstances report vital enchancment after discontinuing statins and initiating mitochondrial help remedy.
This isn’t an argument towards statins. It’s an argument for precision. For pondering past averages. For recognizing that even broadly helpful therapies carry trade-offs, and people trade-offs matter most after they present up in your affected person’s life, not simply within the margins of a medical trial.
How We Discuss About Danger Issues
Christopher Wunsch’s story is uncommon. However his perspective raises questions which are something however.
As clinicians, we’re taught to follow evidence-based medication. We cite landmark trials, calculate danger scores, and prescribe with pointers in thoughts. Statins have remodeled outcomes for sufferers with established atherosclerotic illness, of that there’s no critical debate. However the dialog turns into extra nuanced in main prevention, the place the advantages are smaller and the dangers really feel extra private.
Christopher has spent greater than twenty years not simply therapeutic, however studying. He’s learn the literature that the majority sufferers by no means see. And he’s questioned the assumptions that many people have been taught — not with hostility, however with the readability of somebody who paid the worth.
And therein lies the difficulty. Too usually, we depend on relative danger reductions that sound spectacular however masks the modest absolute advantages in low-risk populations. Too usually, the dialog round statins is framed in binary phrases — take it or don’t — when the truth is way extra individualized.
This isn’t about abandoning statins. It’s about acknowledging that even highly effective therapies include trade-offs. These unintended effects, whereas uncommon, are actual. And that sufferers deserve transparency, not nearly what a drug can do, but in addition about what it may cost a little.
Tales like Christopher’s problem us to re-examine not simply our proof base, however the best way we talk it. They remind us that population-level profit doesn’t all the time align with individual-level expertise — and that medication, at its finest, stays a dialogue, not a directive.
To my fellow statin prescribers:
Once you’re treating somebody for main prevention, pause. Don’t simply ask “Does this affected person qualify?” Ask, “Will this really assist them?” Will years of statin remedy probably scale back their danger in a significant manner? Or are we prescribing extra out of behavior than conviction?
Don’t default to remedy simply to err on the aspect of doing one thing. Prescribe since you’re assured the profit outweighs the burden, for that particular person, not only for the inhabitants. That’s the accountability —and the privilege —of customized care.
A Observe of Gratitude
My honest thanks to Christopher Wunsch for generously sharing his expertise — not solely the medical information, however the private ache, uncertainty, and hard-earned perception that adopted. His braveness, resilience, and dedication to educating others exemplify what it means to flip adversity into advocacy. This article would not exist with out his story, and his mission continues to make a distinction.
I’m additionally profoundly grateful to my pricey pal, Dr. Barbara Roberts, MD, for bringing Christopher’s story to my consideration and connecting us. Her unwavering dedication to difficult assumptions and protecting important conversations alive has helped shine gentle the place it issues most.
Sources & Additional Studying
-
- US Preventive Companies Activity Drive. Statins for the Major Prevention of Cardiovascular Illness in Adults. US Preventive Companies Activity Drive Suggestion Assertion
- Mancini GBJ, Ryomoto A, Yeoh E, Iatan I, Brunham LR, Hegele RA. Reappraisal of statin main prevention trials: implications for identification of the statin-eligible main prevention affected person. Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2025 Feb 25:zwaf048. doi: 10.1093/eurjpc/zwaf048. Epub forward of print. PMID: 39998386
- Thomas JE, Lee N, Thompson PD. Statins frightening MELAS syndrome. A case report. Eur Neurol. 2007;57(4):232-5. doi: 10.1159/000101287. Epub 2007 Mar 26. doi.org/10.1159/000101287
- Ramachandran R, Wierzbicki AS. Statins, Muscle Illness and Mitochondria. J Clin Med. 2017 Jul 25;6(8):75. doi: 10.3390/jcm6080075. PMID: 28757597; PMCID: PMC5575577.
- Ryan TE, Torres MJ, Lin CT, Clark AH, Brophy PM, Smith CA, Smith CD, Morris EM, Thyfault JP, Neufer PD. Excessive-dose atorvastatin remedy progressively decreases skeletal muscle mitochondrial respiratory capability in people. JCI Perception. 2024 Feb 22;9(4):e174125. doi: 10.1172/jci.insight.174125. PMID: 38385748; PMCID: PMC10967389.
- Taylor BA, Thompson PD. Muscle-related side-effects of statins: from mechanisms to evidence-based options. Curr Opin Lipidol. 2015 Jun;26(3):221-7. doi: 10.1097/MOL.0000000000000174. PMID: 25943841.
- Finsterer J, Segall L. Medication interfering with mitochondrial issues. Drug Chem Toxicol. 2010 Apr;33(2):138-51. doi: 10.3109/01480540903207076. PMID: 19839725.
- Golomb BA, Evans MA. Statin adversarial results: a overview of the literature and proof for a mitochondrial mechanism. Am J Cardiovasc Medication. 2008;8(6):373–418. doi.org/10.2165/0129784-200808060-00004
- Larsen S, et al. Simvastatin results on skeletal muscle: relation to decreased mitochondrial operate and oxidative stress. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2013;61(1):44–53. doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2012.09.036
- Mollazadeh H, Tavana E, Fanni G, Bo S, Banach M, Pirro M, von Haehling S, Jamialahmadi T, Sahebkar A. Results of statins on mitochondrial pathways. J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle. 2021 Apr;12(2):237-251. doi: 10.1002/jcsm.12654. Epub 2021 Jan 29. PMID: 33511728; PMCID: PMC8061391.
Parts of this text have been developed with the help of ChatGPT, an AI language mannequin by OpenAI, to assist refine construction, language, and readability whereas preserving the writer’s voice and scientific integrity
Uncover extra from Doc’s Opinion
Subscribe to get the newest posts despatched to your e-mail.
